Open for the 2024 Season May 1st

Angel’s Envy, Elijah Craig, Woodford Reserve, and Old Fitzgerald

The world of bourbon offers a diverse range of flavors and experiences. At the Damascus Old Mill Inn, bourbon enthusiasts can explore an array of premium options, including Pappy Van Winkle 12 Year, Angel’s Envy, Elijah Craig, Woodford Reserve, and Old Fitzgerald. This article aims to provide an in-depth comparison and contrast of these bourbons, highlighting their unique characteristics and helping you make an informed choice.

  1. Pappy Van Winkle 12 Year:
    Pappy Van Winkle 12 Year is a highly sought-after bourbon renowned for its exceptional quality and limited availability. It features a rich, velvety texture with hints of caramel, vanilla, and oak. The 12-year aging process imparts a well-balanced complexity, making it a favorite among bourbon connoisseurs. Pappy Van Winkle’s craftsmanship and smoothness create a benchmark for other bourbons to aspire to.
  2.  Angel’s Envy:
    Angel’s Envy is an intriguing bourbon that sets itself apart with a unique finishing process. After aging in traditional oak barrels, it undergoes an additional period in port wine casks, adding a luscious fruity character. The result is a smooth, medium-bodied bourbon with notes of cherry, toffee, and spice. Angel’s Envy stands out for its innovative approach and balanced sweetness.
  3. Elijah Craig:
    Elijah Craig is a staple in the world of bourbon, renowned for its consistency and value. Named after a pioneering distiller, it offers a rich and full-bodied profile. The flavor profile showcases a blend of caramel, vanilla, and toasted oak, with a hint of cinnamon and nutmeg. With its robust and well-rounded character, Elijah Craig appeals to both seasoned bourbon enthusiasts and newcomers alike.
  4.  Woodford Reserve:
    Woodford Reserve enjoys widespread popularity for its commitment to traditional bourbon-making techniques. It delivers a balanced and complex taste with prominent flavors of dried fruit, vanilla, and toasted oak. Woodford Reserve’s smoothness and attention to detail make it an excellent choice for sipping neat or using as the foundation for classic cocktails.
  5.  Old Fitzgerald:
    Old Fitzgerald is a historic bourbon brand that embraces a weeded bourbon recipe, utilizing a higher percentage of corn and wheat. This approach results in a softer and sweeter flavor profile, accentuated by notes of caramel, butterscotch, and a touch of floral essence. Old Fitzgerald offers a nostalgic experience, harkening back to the golden era of bourbon production.

Comparative Analysis:

a. Flavor Profile:

  • Pappy Van Winkle 12 Year: Rich, velvety, caramel, vanilla, oak.
  • Angel’s Envy: Fruity, cherry, toffee, spice.
  • Elijah Craig: Robust, caramel, vanilla, toasted oak, cinnamon, nutmeg.
  • Woodford Reserve: Balanced, dried fruit, vanilla, toasted oak.
  • Old Fitzgerald: Soft, sweet, caramel, butterscotch, floral.

b. Aging Process:

  • Pappy Van Winkle 12 Year: Aged for 12 years, offering a well-balanced complexity.
  •  Angel’s Envy: Finished in port wine casks for added depth and fruitiness.
  • Elijah Craig: Aged for a minimum of 4 years, contributing to its robustness.
  • Woodford Reserve: Aged for an average of 7 years, ensuring a balanced flavor profile.
  • Old Fitzgerald: Aged for various periods, resulting in a matured and refined taste.

c. Smoothness:

  • Pappy Van Winkle 12 Year: Renowned for its exceptional smoothness.
  • Angel’s Envy: Smooth and approachable, with a balanced sweetness.
  • Elijah Craig: Offers a smooth and enjoyable sipping experience.
  • Woodford Reserve: Known for its smooth and refined character.
  • Old Fitzgerald: Exhibits a gentle and soft mouthfeel.


When comparing Pappy Van Winkle 12 Year to other top bourbons available at the Damascus Old Mill Inn, including Angel’s Envy, Elijah Craig, Woodford Reserve, and Old Fitzgerald, each offers its own distinct flavor profile and characteristics. Pappy Van Winkle stands as a benchmark for quality and complexity, while Angel’s Envy impresses with its unique finishing process. Elijah Craig offers a robust and well-rounded experience, Woodford Reserve focuses on balance and tradition, and Old Fitzgerald delivers a softer and sweeter alternative.

Ultimately, the choice among these exceptional bourbons will depend on your personal preferences and desired tasting experience. Whether you seek a rich and velvety texture, fruity notes with a hint of spice, robustness, balance, or a nostalgic journey, the Damascus Old Mill Inn’s bourbon selection has something to cater to every bourbon enthusiast’s taste.